In 2014, a little-known shoe brand called Allbirds started selling wool sneakers online. Within 12 months, they were worn by celebrities, praised by Vogue, and outselling brands that had been around for decades – all without competing on price.
They didn’t invent a new type of footwear. They didn’t undercut competitors on price. Instead, they made people feel something their competitors couldn’t replicate – and that feeling spread faster than any ad campaign.
The lesson here isn’t about sneakers. It’s about the hidden principles that turn a product into a movement. Harley Finkelstein, President of Shopify and the man who’s seen more DTC success stories than anyone, calls it “owning mindshare.” Emily Heyward, co-founder of the award-winning branding agency Red Antler, responsible for breakout DTC successes like Casper and Allbirds, calls it “creating emotional resonance.” Ezra Firestone, an e-commerce veteran who has built eight-figure stores and taught thousands of founders, calls it “building a personality that sells.”
And there’s one bonus principle you’ll see at the end that separates good brands from cult brands – and once you notice it, you’ll see it everywhere.
Most DTC brands think branding is about logos and ad campaigns, when in reality, it’s about controlling the story people tell themselves. That story makes customers willing to pay more, stay longer, and talk about you for free. Ignore it, and your business becomes a commodity – fighting over discounts and ad spend.
The difference between a forgettable brand and a cult-like one isn’t budget or luck – it’s the application of these hidden branding principles.
They focus on a single emotional trigger, not a dozen mixed messages.
Most DTC founders try to make their brand “everything” to everyone – and end up becoming nothing to anyone. Allbirds didn’t try to compete on style, price, and variety all at once. They chose comfort and sustainability – and stuck with it. Harley Finkelstein calls this “owning one word in the customer’s mind.”
The brain craves shortcuts, and a single emotional trigger acts like a mental bookmark. Think about the candle brand that’s all about calm – from the scent to the handwritten thank-you card. Or the fitness apparel company that screams power in every ad, photo, and product detail. Too many messages create friction and confusion, making you harder to remember. A single trigger makes your story simple to retell – and retelling is the currency of brand growth.
The fastest-growing brands don’t have the widest message. They have the sharpest one. That’s what makes them instantly recognizable in a crowded feed. If customers can’t sum up your brand in one emotion, you’ve already lost mindshare.
They turn their customers into the marketing department.
The most valuable ad campaigns in the world are free – and run by your customers. Harley Finkelstein notes that high-loyalty brands often have the lowest acquisition costs. They design experiences so customers want to talk about them.
Instead of “How do we get more buyers?” they ask, “How do we make buyers our promoters?”
One skincare founder once handwrote 50 thank-you notes during her first month of sales. Customers started posting them on Instagram, tagging the brand, and telling friends. That single act created a wave of referrals – all before she spent a dollar on ads.
Referral programs and surprise gifts can do the same thing, but only if they’re authentic. Over time, these organic mentions work harder than any Facebook ad budget ever could.
When customers feel invested in your success, they protect and promote your brand. This is how loyalty compounds into market dominance. Paid ads become an amplifier, not your lifeline. Your most powerful growth channel is already in your customer’s pocket – their phone, and the people they text.
They stand for something outside their product category.
The strongest brands sell beliefs, not products. Emily Heyward’s agency Red Antler has helped build brands where the mission outshines the merchandise. Patagonia sells jackets, but really they sell environmental activism. Warby Parker sells glasses, but really they sell accessible vision for all.
This shift changes the customer’s question from “What do they sell?” to “What do they believe?” One founder of a reusable water bottle brand said, “We’re not selling bottles. We’re selling the end of single-use plastics.” That cause becomes the reason people choose you over cheaper alternatives. It also gives you an infinite well of stories to tell, all tied to a core belief. Missions are magnetic because they invite people to belong, not just buy.
Founders who ignore this miss the emotional layer that creates superfans. Products wear out; beliefs endure. If you want to own mindshare, stand for something timeless. The brand that stands for something more will always outlast the one that just sells “stuff.”
Bonus: They make their brand a character people want to hang out with.
People buy from people – or at least from brands that feel human. Ezra Firestone teaches that personality is a conversion tool. It breaks through the sameness of “professional” branding. It gives customers a sense that the brand “gets them.”
Whether it’s humor, boldness, empathy, or quirkiness, personality is what makes you memorable. Think about Duolingo’s sassy owl or Liquid Death’s over-the-top metal persona. A strong brand character turns transactions into relationships. When customers feel connected, they’re more forgiving, more loyal, and more vocal. It’s the difference between being a supplier and being a friend.
In crowded markets, sameness is death. A brand with character becomes a familiar face customers look for. That familiarity is what drives repeat purchases and organic buzz. In branding, being liked is nice – but being loved is unforgettable.
Mindshare Is the Only Moat That Lasts
In DTC, the only competitive advantage that compounds over time is how deeply you live in your customer’s mind. Products can be copied. Prices can be undercut. Ad channels can dry up overnight.
But a brand that owns mindshare becomes bulletproof. Harley Finkelstein’s “one word in the customer’s mind,” Emily Heyward’s “emotional resonance,” and Ezra Firestone’s “personality that sells” are all different ways of saying the same thing: when people think of your category, your brand is the first name that comes to mind.
That position isn’t bought – it’s built through clarity, advocacy, belief, and character. It’s why some brands can charge more, spend less on ads, and still grow faster.
Every principle you’ve read here is a lever for building that kind of mental monopoly. Apply them consistently and the compounding effect will be unstoppable. Skip them, and you’ll be just another name in the discount pile.
The question is: how long will you let your competitors own more of your customer’s mind than you do?
If this resonated, here’s what to do next:
→ If you’re tired of content that fills space instead of driving sales, let’s talk. Schedule a quick demo.
→ If you’re ready to turn product pages, email flows, landing copy, and more into silent salespeople for your brand, subscribe to either our Unlimited Standard Plan or Unlimited Professional Plan to get started.
Your story deserves better than generic copy.
We make it unforgettable.